I Scream Cakes Ice Cream of the Month Club

Give the perfect gift to the
ice cream lover in your life.

Treat the ice cream lover in your life (even if it’s yourself) to the perfect gift that keeps giving all year long. Select your membership level below or call us today!

Join Today!


All club memberships 10% off until January 1, 2016!

(Discount reflected in price below. Hurry! Order before prices go up!)

About Our Ice Cream

I Scream Cakes' premium ice creams are lovingly handcrafted from the finest ingredients, including organic dairy, sugar, and eggs. Our unique flavors are derived from real food, including herbs, spices, fruits, nuts, beers, and liquors.


Our PintPLUS container is an odd shaped container that is 25% larger than a standard pint. It is compostable (the lid is recyclable), and wider mouth that makes for easier scooping. I Scream Cakes is a proud member of the Green Dining Alliance. 99% of our packaging and containers (and spoons!) are compostable, made from plants.

Pickup and Delivery

Club members can pick up their ice cream at the store during regular business hours starting on the first Tuesday of every other month (Feb, Apr, Jun, Aug, Oct, Dec).

Delivery is available to all parts of St. Louis County for an additional charge. Add delivery: within St. Louis city limits is $36, within 10 miles (Kirkwood area) is $75, and 20 miles (Ballwin area) is $100.


Our "staple" flavors available all year are:

  • All Organic Vanilla Bean
  • Ecuadorian Chocolate
  • Peanut Butter 'n' Chocolate
  • Blueberry Cheesecake*
  • Black and Tan* (chocolate Guinness Stout ice cream marbled with a malted Bass Ale ice cream)
  • Orange-Habañero Chocolate
  • Vegan Peanut Butter 'n' Chocolate-Banana

Seasonal features we’ve featured in the past include:

  • Pistachio Caramel
  • Lavender Lemon Swirl
  • Pineappleño
  • Elviscream
  • 4Hands' Chocolate Milk Stout*
  • Goat Figure* (goat cheese pumpkin ale ice cream with a fig swirl)

Former featured vegan ice cream flavors:

  • Tastes Like Purple (a fusion of berries and flowers)
  • Mango Mojito
  • Chocolate-Strawberry Sorbet
  • Kentucky Kiss (cherry bourbon vanilla)
I Scream Monthly Basic Level

Basic Membership – $169

The I Scream Monthy Basic Membership is guaranteed to bring a smile to the face of any ice cream lover! Every other month you or that special someone will receive two different PintPLUS (18oz) containers of our premium, all-natural ice cream, carefully selected by our ice cream gourmets. Each pickup/delivery period, you’ll receive one of our house staples and one seasonal flavor.

Dog Lovers Membership – $221

Need a gift for your best friend and man’s best friend? The Dog Lovers membership level is for you. Every pickup/delivery period, Dog Lover members will receive 8 doggy-style bones along with their two PintPLUSes. Doggy-style treats are made with yogurt, egg, sweet potato, peanut butter, bacon, and coconut oil – no sugar, no cream.

I Scream Monthly Basic Level
I Scream Monthly Basic Level

Deluxe Membership – $399

Just can’t get enough of that sweet stuff? Then double your pleasure with the Deluxe memberhsip.

Deluxe members will receive FOUR pints of ice cream (2 staple, 2 seasonal) PLUS two truck treat every other month.

Start enjoying our delicious ISCREAM and a tasty drumstick or cookie sandwich today!